Skip to main content

GANDHI, THOREAU, AND A SHIP OF THESEUS


The political journey of Mahatma (Gandhi) though started from South Africa, however, his spiritual journey owes much  to the literary stalwarts like Tolstoy, Ruskin, Thoreau, and Emerson. What did really transform him, was his ability to share a space with the greatest thinkers, poets, and storytellers of that era. One of them was David Henry Thoreau. It is a well established fact that Gandhian method of Civil Disobedience was originally imagined by Thoreau, however, a wise Man like M.K. Gandhi, without being a 'Professor of Ideas', became truly a philosopher (Bilgrami, Gandhi: The Philosopher), an activist who practically implemented those ideas in toto, sometimes with flexibility, and elevated the scope of 'Potentiality into Actuality' (Georgio Agamben, Homo Sacer). Thoreau in his introductory remarks rightly says, "There  are nowadays professors of philosophy, but not philosophers. Yet it is admirable to profess because it was once admirable to live" (Thoreau, Walden). 'A ship of Theseus' between a naturalist (Thoreau) and a humanist (Gandhi) was of course their ability to live with what they believed in and sincerity to believe what they lived with. Nevertheless, they never imposed their value of truth on others. Thoreau even went on questioning the very idea of truth what old men preach to have with them. D.H. Thoreau writes in Walden:

"One may almost doubt if the wisest man has learned anything of absolute value by living. Practically, the old have no very important advice to give the young, their own experience has been so partial, and their lives have been such miserable failures, for private reasons, as they must believe; and it may be that they have some faith left which belies that experience" (Thoreau, Walden).

Thoreau revered the solitude, than the deceitful companionship of fellow neighbours, friends, or relatives. Gandhi however, was an advocate of a 'Community Life'; like the transformation of 'being' into 'collective being'; an organic view of life. His ideas about "Village Republic" was discarded as the romantic and Utopian idea, a fashionable term of pacifists who love humanisation and rationalization of existing structure so as to stifle every progressive or out-of-fashion ideas to come. (R.M. Unger).

Thoreau, like Gandhi, was a dreamer, an achiever, a romantic poet who loves living than anything else. His erudite remark in Walden at least suggests so:

"I did not wish to live what was not life, living is so dear; nor did I wish to practise resignation, unless it was quite necessary. I wanted to live deep and suck out all the marrow of life, to live so sturdily and Spartan-like as to put to rout all that was not life". (Thoreau, Walden).

For Gandhi, life was more than a heroic adventurism. His 'Satyagrahi' was a devotee of truth, sacrifice, and non-violence; one who relies on 'soul-force' instead of 'Brute Force'. 

It is to my mind a 'Sisiphusean task' to summarize Gandhi and Thoreau in few paragraphs. Every time one tries to imprison them in few words, each moment those words would be ashamed of its limited ability, or rather inability to express those gigantic ideas with clarity. Here I avoid conclusion, because, to conclude is kill the curiosity. The curiosity inspires us to enjoy melody and harmony more than anything else.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Physical Basis of Conscious Life: A Synthesis of William James's Physiological Psychology

I Introduction: Bridging Physiology and Psychology William James, in his landmark work The Principles of Psychology, provides a foundational framework connecting the brain's physiological mechanisms to the purposive, selective, and unified nature of conscious mental life. This blog analyzes James’s synthesis, which grounds psychological phenomena in the material workings of the nervous system without reducing consciousness to a mere epiphenomenon. We will explore his hierarchical model of the brain, which evolves from simple reflex actions in the lower nerve centers to the complex, deliberative functions of the cerebrum. Key themes include the role of the cerebrum as an organ of foresight and prudence, the physiological mechanism of habit as the process by which experience physically imprints itself upon the brain’s plastic matter, and consciousness's essential function as a “selecting agency” that is causally efficacious in steering the organism toward its own interests. Ultim...

Martin Heidegger's Deconstruction of the History of Ontology

I  Introduction In the opening pages of his magnum opus, Being and Time, Martin Heidegger resurrects a question he argues has been buried for millennia, framing his entire project with an epigraph from Plato’s Sophist: “For manifestly you have long been aware of what you mean when you use the expression ‘being’. We, however, who used to think we understood it, have now become perplexed.” This is no mere academic exercise but a deliberate reawakening of what Heidegger argues is the most fundamental and, paradoxically, the most forgotten question in the history of Western thought. For Heidegger, a pervasive “forgetfulness of Being” has characterized philosophy since antiquity, where the initial, vibrant inquiry into what it means “to be” solidified into a series of unexamined dogmas. The question was not answered and then set aside; rather, it fell into obscurity, concealed by the very traditions that were supposed to preserve it. This blog argues that Heidegger's critical "dest...

Sterile Preoccupation: Towards Technocracy and Loss of Human

William Blake, Newton (1795 ) Roland Barthes reminds us, looks us back from his grave, and constantly warns us about the mythological character of human life, our society, and the relationship of human with the life-systems, whereas symbolic profusions outweigh rational contemplation, emotive appeals are strategically manoeuvred for the deceptive promises and considerations, rhetorical narratives are deployed to symbolize the virtue of unbounded eloquences, significances, and exemplifying extravagances of meanings, ritualistic and mechanical productions of narratives, and seductions towards efficacy as instrumentalised worldview have relegated human relationships to the status of mechanization and technocratizations. What is so significant about the mechanisation of thinking and ritualistic institutionalisation? If not the loss of humanistic elements in the human relationships and the relationships of human species from their nature, ecosystem, and the life-systems itself. What is so p...